Morgan Stanley Shifts Stance on flatexDEGIRO
Morgan Stanley has revised its outlook on flatexDEGIRO AG, removing the German online brokerage from its preferred list of picks. According to the financial institution, customer growth decelerated to approximately 9% year-on-year in October. This slowdown casts doubt on whether management can achieve its targeted customer growth of at least 10% for the full year 2026 without an exceptionally strong performance in November and December, with full-year expansion now projected near 9.5%.
Escalating Customer Acquisition Costs
A key driver behind the reassessment is the deterioration of customer acquisition economics. During the first nine months of 2026, acquisition expenses averaged roughly €126 per customer, representing a considerable increase from the €73 recorded during the same period in the previous year. Although expenses moderated to about €88 in the third quarter compared to €139 across the first half, they remained above the roughly €60 level seen in the comparable prior-year period. Morgan Stanley anticipates that these outlays will remain structurally elevated within the €120 to €122 range as the brokerage continues investing to revitalize expansion.
Intensified Competition and Regional Expansion
The competitive landscape in Germany has intensified significantly, with upcoming pension reforms shifting market competition away from basic transaction fees toward comprehensive savings products, cash returns, and retirement planning solutions. Meanwhile, international expansion efforts in Spain, France, and Italy necessitate additional capital outlays for localized product development, distribution networks, customer service capabilities, and marketing campaigns, raising concerns that elevated expenditures will take longer to yield meaningful returns.
Earnings Revisions and Corporate Governance
Reflecting softer commission revenues, decelerated user growth, and heavier reinvestment needs, Morgan Stanley adjusted its earnings forecasts downward by 4% to 6% for the 2026 through 2028 period. The bank also pointed to recent departures from the board of directors, vacancies on the supervisory board, and a transition toward a dual-Chief Executive Officer structure as elements introducing uncertainty regarding strategic execution and priorities.
Structural Tailwinds and Market Performance
Despite the near-term headwinds, the broker acknowledges underlying structural support stemming from broader retail investor participation, flatexDEGIRO’s established footprint across Europe, and the possibility of future operating leverage. Projections continue to point toward mid-teens growth in adjusted net income spanning 2026 to 2028. Market-wise, the equity has retreated roughly 35% over a three-month horizon—outpacing a 12% decline among global peer companies—and finished trading at €22.94 on November 9.
