Monday.com Ltd (MNDY) reported its financial results for the third quarter of fiscal year 2026, beating analyst estimates on both top and bottom lines. Despite the stronger-than-expected figures, shares declined, trading at $82.09 down 6.64% as of November 9 at 3:03 PM EST. The market reaction reflected concerns over forward guidance rather than the quarterly beat itself.
During the third quarter of fiscal year 2026, revenue reached $377.5 million, surpassing the $369.2 million estimate and representing a 19% increase year over year. Adjusted earnings per share came in at $2.14, exceeding the $1.37 expected by the market. Historical performance shows a pattern where quarterly revenue and earnings beats have not translated into positive stock price reactions. Previous quarters also posted beats, such as Q4 FY25 with revenue of $333.9 million versus $329.5 million estimated, Q1 FY26 with revenue of $351.3 million versus $339.3 million estimated, Q2 FY26 with revenue of $364.6 million versus $355.6 million estimated, and Q3 FY26 with revenue of $377.5 million against $369.2 million. Investors appear to be pricing in growth durability rather than the magnitude of the quarterly beats.
Several key questions were addressed by management during the quarter. Regarding artificial intelligence monetization, leadership noted a nice uptick in AI Annual Recurring Revenue. Co-CEO Roy Mann explained that usage-based credits function primarily as additive components to seats and recurring revenue rather than replacements. On headless and Model Context Protocol (MCP) usage, over 75 million MCP requests have been recorded, with the company maintaining no current plans for separate monetization, opting instead to charge exclusively through seats and usage. The full-year outlook was raised or reaffirmed, pointing to revenue between $1.473 billion and $1.475 billion, reflecting 20% growth, along with non-GAAP operating income of $268 million to $270 million and adjusted free cash flow between $282 million and $288 million. Profitability metrics indicated a guided Q4 operating margin of approximately 18%, while foreign exchange headwinds are anticipated to reduce margins by 100 to 200 basis points.
At the same time, several questions and challenges remained open. Growth deceleration emerged as a primary driver of the sell-off, with Q4 revenue guidance projected at $380 million to $382 million, implying growth of approximately 14%, down from 19% in Q3. Downmarket weakness was highlighted by the Chief Revenue Officer, who stated that the lower end continues to decelerate, the top of the funnel is not improving, and small-and-medium business logo churn has increased. Sales disruption questions persist, with the CRO noting it is too early to determine if effects from a recent reduction in force have cleared, requesting a couple more months of data. Net dollar retention stood at 108% in Q3, with the Chief Financial Officer expecting a decline to about 107% under guidance that assumes no macroeconomic improvement extending into 2027. Gross margin narrowed to 88% compared to 90% in the prior-year period due to increasing investments in artificial intelligence and services.
Looking ahead, several upcoming catalysts are on the horizon. Q4 FY26 earnings are anticipated around early February 2027, with consensus estimates standing at $1.55 for earnings per share and $385.65 million for revenue, figures that sit above management's guidance range of $380 million to $382 million and potentially signal stretched expectations. Over a 90-day period, earnings per share estimates increased by 4.5% while revenue estimates remained flat, with consensus for fiscal year 2027 projected at $6.70 for earnings per share and $1.69 billion for revenue. Management also plans to share initial thoughts on fiscal year 2027 guidance as the organizational transformation runs through 2027. Additionally, the monday Frontier hiring initiative for its new AI-implementation organization will be monitored to see whether it supports upmarket expansion or puts pressure on margins, alongside tracking signs of recovery in upmarket sales from reduction in force disruptions and continued seat expansion and AI credit consumption in larger accounts.
Market perspectives present a split view. Bullish viewpoints point out that the stock is down 44.7% year-to-date, with a PEG ratio cited at 0.14, alongside intact profit and cash-flow guidance and growing artificial intelligence usage. Bearish perspectives emphasize decelerating growth dropping to the low teens, sliding net dollar retention, and management commentary indicating that stability is several quarters away, while noting that beats have not halted multiple compression. The stock exhibits a one-year performance of -56.70%, a year-to-date change of -44.69%, and a 52-week trading range spanning from $57.50 to $169.76.
